The funny thing is that White Knuckle did not invent computers, sports video games, the Internet, or software that allows updates from a server. However, it claims to have invented a system that involves all of these components. The USPTO gave White Knuckle the patent rights on the grounds that the specific application of these elements on a single idea (updating sports video games using software over the Internet) is enough to grant White Knuckle the rights.
This is clearly abuse of the patent system by trolls. White Knuckle used this patent to sue Electronic Arts among other video game companies on the basis of patent infringement. The troll, much like the one in my other post, received settlement money from more than a few companies because the patent covers all software that allows for system updates over a live server.
Hi Healy,
ReplyDeleteGreat choice! I like how you mentioned that this patent is owned by a patent troll, since we just talked about that last week. I would suggest relating this to some requirements of patents - such as obviousness or usefulness.
Hi Healy,
ReplyDeleteGreat choice for a silly patent! I definitely this is one that shouldn't have been granted to White Knuckle. I like the background explanation, but like Caley said, relating this patent to obviousness or usefulness, or describing the claims of the patents would be helpful for the reader.
Hi Healy,
ReplyDeleteReally enjoyed your background information and description behind the patent. However I definitely agree with Pranay and Caley, it would be very useful to provide some analysis behind the issue of the patent.
Hey! This is such a silly patent! Thanks for sharing :) I like how you were somewhat concise in your summary of the patent, but next time explain obviousness/novelty too!
ReplyDelete